Generative grammar theory of linquistics

Generative grammar is the idea that although our brains are limited; and our experience with a language is always limited, as we have not herd all possible combinations of native or secondary language. However, we have an innate ability to generate and understand an infinite number of combinations of sentences.  This mean although I have never herd a combination of works in a particular sequence, I will be able to understand it. Further, although I have never herd a sentence or grammar structure, I will be able to create a sentence.  There is a finite set of grammar rules in a language. Noam Chomsky is the originator of the theory of generative grammar.  Many linguists love Chomsky and talk about his theories all the time. As a human I think he has male a huge contribution to linguistics.

 
Although I have not give this much though, I would say my first reaction is, with all due respect, its a nice theory but has limited practical application and further not fully true. I can generally make sentences and create sentence in Polish that are grammatically correct. However, if I have not herd a sequence, even in a limited way it would be very hard to be perfectly correct.  Further, when I give Polish native speakers crazy fun tests on their own grammar, they do not know it.  I will take foreign or fictional or elf language words or strange ideas and ask them to make a sentence with all the proper word endings etc, and they have to think about and debate the declinations and grammar, as they have never herd such word declinations. Even if there is a rule they do not have an innate feel for it, they have to start thinking. Many times they will get it wrong according to the rule and say, ‘oh well we do not usually change foreign’ words or phrases. This is true, but the point is its hard for them to self generate Polish grammar which they have not herd or encountered.  Maybe I am missing the point with generative grammar linguistic theory, but in reality it never sat well with me. I think you need massive exposure to a language to speak it.

2 Comments on Generative grammar theory of linquistics»

  1. Roop Chand said,

    March 28, 2008at 12:45 am

    need to learn

  2. Milan said,

    May 23, 2008at 8:46 pm

    Ahm… I think you’ve been just too frustrated trying to learn the language and I do know how stressful declinations can be. I’m not Polish. I’m Serb but since my language also has declinations, I suppose the complexity is similar.
    Depending on the education of the particular individual, you’ll encounter native speakers of every language who are not too familiar with their own grammar.
    So it depends how you chose your Polish test subjects.

    You definitely right about the importance of language exposure, particularly when it comes to spoken language.

RSS Comments Feed RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URL

Leave a Comment on Generative grammar theory of linquistics

Related posts to Generative grammar theory of linquistics

Why language classes do not work

Why taking language classes do not work Language classes can work but more times than not, do not teach the student the language. Why? Most people

Accent or grammar

What gives away a foreigner when trying to speak a language accent or grammar Accent If you want to sound like a native what will give you away, 

One world language

Linguists have dubbed it "proto-world" or "proto-sapiens." language The idea that all human language has a common root is a controversial theory, but even more is

Teach to learn

Teach to learn A very effective method for learning foreign languages, particularly grammar is teaching it. Many classes I ask a student to prepare a

How to learn grammar in a foreign language

How to learn grammar in a foreign language There are two ways to learn grammar as an adult foreign language learner, abstraction or memorization. Method 1, learning


Fatal error: Out of memory (allocated 31457280) (tried to allocate 8192 bytes) in /homepages/18/d95001024/htdocs/blog/wp-content/plugins/alinks/includes/Alinks/Cacher/File.php on line 297